Ironwolf vs wd red reddit. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast.
Ironwolf vs wd red reddit. Please advise as noise is something very critical to me. Thoughts on WD vs Seagate? I've always bought WD Red, but with the recent WD controversies (including the SMR/CMR scandal and the recent WDDA warning), I'm considering Seagate. a few days for Seagate. The best value drives I've found are the WD White Label drives in the WD Elements, WD Easystore ( BestBuy only), and the WD MyBook Drives. Where I live that amounts to $20/year. Oct 9, 2024 · When NAS is considered, for me, the choice narrows down to WD Red and Seagate IronWolf. TIA Archived post. I don't know for Seagate, but all 18TB WD drives are based on the same hardware. Currently, I have this backup setup, running on my old still-on-Windows7 PC with 8 GB RAM and using an old ASUS H81M-A MOBO (dating back from 2017, or maybe even earlier, I forgot!), with only PCIe 2. Ultrastar - Longest warranty, however - may be SMR, but very dubious? WD Red - Seems to be favoured by this subreddit quite heavily Ironwolf - Mixed reliability Overall, the Ultrastar is probably the most reliable, and has the longest warranty but it depends on whether it's SMR or not; if it is WD Red may be the best for your circumstances. Just another Sticker, Firmware and specs ( Workload, warranty and so on ) they gurantee. Both are CMR. I'm looking for a new Hard drive for my PC, a NAS one so in the future I just need to buy at least other equal drive to mount a DIY NAS. Regarding your constraints, Ironwolf has very similar noise signature and better reliability reputation (no marketing mess with SMR, RPM, running cooler, IronWolf Health Hey OP. A. 175MB/s for the red. Also, I can't find any difference between the IronWolf Pro and Exos drives. Your NAS is on 24 hours a day, constantly writing and reading data. Any suggestions which one to We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Feb 7, 2025 · While we may not have specific reliability data for the IronWolf and RED drives, one cloud storage provider regularly publishes drive failure data for all the drives it uses – Backblaze. I We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. A NAS is probably idle 80-90% of the time, but consumption will of course be higher with load. What are the differences between Seagate IronWolf 4TB ST4000VN006 and Western Digital Red Plus 4TB WD40EFPX? Analyze head-to-head all specifications and features to find out the better hard disk. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. $150 cheaper from my vendor. I am buying Synology DS920+ but can’t make up my mind on which NAS HD to buy (WD Red or Seagate IronWolf). May 3, 2023 · 12tb Ironwolf pro or 12tb WD Red+ ?? Use NAS drives. Seagate Ironwolf vs Western Digital Red Planning to buy a 4TB internal HDD for my build. The drives lower the temperature with the automatically changing rotation speed that they have. Model# is the same. I would go nuts if I filled a Synology NAS at home with Exos. Seagate Ironwolf are cheaper and Jul 6, 2023 · This post shows you Seagate IronWolf vs WD Red specifications and lists some factors you should take into consideration when purchasing a NAS drive. Since you plan to have 12 drives, I would go with WD pro, rather than plus (plus are recommended in systems with up to 8 drives). Seagate Ironwolf are cheaper and We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. But in the last 2 years I purchased 2 Seagate drives one Exos (noisy but fast) and the Ironwolf. Now, would it make sense for me to buy the WD drives, sending back the Seagate ones? (I still don't know the production date of the drives) We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Hence my conclusion is for home use if placed in an office where noise matters, Red Plus maybe the best option. SSD's can fail just like HDD's. Please note that the Seagate hard drives they use are the Exos variety, not Ironwolf. I read Ironwolf are a little louder than WD. Also for the love of all things good, please remove the packing tape from the front! Everywhere I look the Skyhawk seems to be cheaper than the WD drive. I bought some 8TB Seagate Ironwolf drives on Amazon. WD RMA is a mess, their agents seem to be offshore and not empowered to fix / resolve issues; Seagate support is mostly in North America, if any issue comes up, they can expedite. I'm tossing together another 1821+ and was looking for drives and the Seagate is significantly cheaper than the WD red pro. 5 Hi there I just wanted to share my experience with two 6TB drives: -WD Red Plus WD60EFZX -Seagate IronWolf ST6000VN001 both bought around September to November 2021. Not much expwrience with Ironwolfs but WD RMA process is awesome and you dont need them often anyways as they barely break. Mar 14, 2025 · WD Red vs. For me the want was a drive array that would last ten years. I'm looking for a couple of quiet 18TB drives. I bought a Synology 1520+ and put the Ironwolfs in there, well knowing that the internet says the IronWolfs are louder than the WDs. as far as i can tell, standard drives are not exactly suitable for the 8-14 hour days that i put them through. Hey r/DataHoarder ! It’s been almost a decade since I dealt with storage, and as such I need a bit of help. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Both drives are 24/7rated, both drives come with 3years warranty. Both of them have almost the same RPM, Cache and Price. The question is simple. Is there a reason for this? Looking at the specs there doesn't seem to be a great deal of difference between the two. I currently go for the Exos. I will be buying two of these drives for RAID. Amazon. Is it worth the extra cost of getting a surveillance drive or are your standard iron wolf NAS drives going to be sufficient when my numbers will remain small? I'm looking at getting a Seagate Exos 7E8 6TB or the Seagate IronWolf 6TB (is the IronWorlf Pro worth upgrading to). So far I haven't made any negative experiences with either the Ironwolf or Exos. WD Red/Gold/Black are meant for high performance use cases and usually spin a lot faster and generate more heat. I upgraded to the WD Ultrastar product line from WD Red for my NAS can't figure out why the Retail packaging of WD Ultrastar is priced lower than the WD RED while all the specs are better. Normally I would just buy another WD red plus but afer the whole "Warning" issue I don't know if I even want to deal with WD anymore. I need more space and want to upgrade to 12TB. Note: Even quiet HDDs make noise when they're working hard. Should I choose WD Reds or Seagate Ironwolf drives? Seagate is cheaper with 20$ where I live. WD Red Plus: Supposedly a little louder than the IronWolf Non-Pro. WD Red Pro is obnoxious at idle, Seagate IronWolf Pro is obnoxious while active. All drives are CMR. So why settle with 2TB less. I understand the WD is 5640rpm instead of 7200, but with 1 user (2 on very rare occasions) would the WD be a better choice? The WD Red Pro and Seagate IronWolf Pro are the enhanced “Pro” versions of their respective NAS drive ranges. 512MB cache. We’ve written up comprehensive guides on Western Digital Red, Red Plus, and Red Pro as well as Seagate IronWolf vs. I will be populating my 24-bay storage server and am wondering if a ~$75 difference between each drive is really worth the investment I haven't used the WD Red so far because they were always more expensive than the others you have listed. Secondary purpose - in the future, might try it for maybe Plex for our home. What are your thoughts/recommendations? Obviously the main choices are: - Western Digital Red or Red Pro - Seagate IronWolf - Toshiba N300 Can anyone point me towards a demonstrable advantage to one of these choices? Is there a contender I missed? HGST perhaps? The price/performance seem to be nearly on par across the board. Looks like UniFi is out of the 8 TB hard drives for the NVR. The enterprise drives have different sound profiles but require careful chassis damping to avoid thumping everything nearby. Today I found that the Red Pros costs 140€/each. Anti-vibration sensors also protect the drives from the vibrations of the NAS. And i assume Drives which i bought before is a cause. They tell you "this is the drive you need in your private NAS" and then sell you overpriced drives with a high margin. Still, it gives us some sense of how reliable the Seagate brand is. Not that I really care or worry too much, but what is the significance, if any? Jul 31, 2024 · Best NAS drives You should only be buying these drives for your NAS. Personally I’ve selected Seagate IronWolf 6TB for my Synology 716+, and WD Red 4x4TB +2x6TB for my DYI NAS. One of the 3 I bought has a different (red) label. I do not like my read / write speed. What am I missing? I recently decided on and bought 10x IronWolf PRO 16tb as the mean time between failures looked good as did the price per tb. Aug 27, 2024 · Hi, so I have a Synlogy with a 4 HDD array using WD Red (8TB). I recently decided on and bought 10x IronWolf PRO 16tb as the mean time between failures looked good as did the price per tb. Anyways thinking about getting an Ironwolf 10 TB. ordered 2. Seagate Ironwolf vs WD red 4TB? i need more storage, and with the way that i basically abuse any storage drive i get my hands on, i thought i should probably go for a NAS HDD this time around. I have an Ironwolf Pro and a Red Pro in a DS216+II. When you pair IronWolf and 4TB+ capacities of IronWolf & IronWolf Pro, you get an extra baked in drive monitoring feature that extends beyond traditional S. My last WD RMA 6 weeks ago, WD shipped me a DOA Red drive, what a PITA to replace. But since I'd only be copying raw footage on the drive after editing (and possibly back and forth on my editing machine once in a blue moon as I'd need that footage) I started to consider WD Blue as a cost effective alternative. WD 14tb at $243. Thoughts? First I thought the WD Purple would be reliable/high quality because it’s meant for 24/7 surveillance use and I would only use it occasionally so it wouldn’t even have to bear that sort of strain. Synology's Plus HAT3300 drives are rebranded Seagate Ironwolf drives with a huge price increase. On the other hand, I there were several accounts of people saying the WD purples break quickly/often. The idea was to have 8TB of usable space, so I bought 3 x 4TB Ironwolf Pro (at a price of 145€/each) (they are arriving today). Noise-wise it seems on par with an IronWolf, but cheaper. I would love to try 14-16TB Ironwolf pro or WD Red Plus to see if they have the same noise at idling like their server versions. These should aid you in better understanding the differences between the family of drives. Likely to have 4-5, 5MP cameras on continuous recording. I’m about to populate a Synology NAS, but need input on which drives to get. Ironwolf pro 16tb at $249. Does any one have any sort of experience with the difference between these two product lines? I understand that they the WD Red and standard IronWolf drives are rated for 8 drive enclosures while the WD Red Pros and IronWolf Pros are rated for 24 bay enclosures. Right now i am at point where i want to upgrade drive. com: Western Digital 4TB WD Red Plus NAS Internal Hard Drive HDD - 5400 RPM, SATA 6 Gb/s, CMR, 128 MB Cache, 3. Last few WD RMAs have taken close to a month to process vs. In the past I have had bad experiences with Seagate going bad just after warranty expires, while WD would last longer than warranty (this is my personal experience, others may have a different experience). Let's say for example I want to pair an 8TB WD Red with an 8TB Iron wolf. Afaik it varies greatly between models and capacity. Nov 23, 2022 · Unsure which hard drive to go for? We’ve tried and tested the Seagate Ironwolf and WD Red to settle scores and find the best hard drive for you! Seagate 8 TB 7200 RPM matchup: Ironwolf normal vs Pro vs NAS vs Pro NAS vs EXOS: What's the exact diff? I'm looking to buy 2 new HDD to make my backups of my home data. Western Digital Red 3TB drives after 6. Toshiba I know this has been discussed a few times before but I don't think the 18TB has been discussed. I’ve upgraded to Seagate Iron Wolf 10TB now and they are actually louder. Any comment on either of those or other HDDs? Looking for a 6TB HDD to record two (minimum) 4K 8MP cameras 24x7x365. I have Synolgy DS220+ and when i bought it (about 1-2 years ago), i messed up and got 2x 4tb SMR drives Barracudas. Dec 17, 2024 · Currently considering: WD Red Plus vs Red Pro Seagate IronWolf vs IronWolf Pro I’m mainly using the NAS for OBS recordings, video editing, and general long-term storage. Any thoughts or experiences in this regard? Noise levels of 18 TB drives WD vs. Because most complaints I saw on the Ironwolf pro were the noise and power efficiency, I ordered the WD. 3 years. Anyone have experience with both? This is for my 923+ which is replacing my 718 What are the differences between Seagate IronWolf 4TB ST4000VN006 and Western Digital Red Plus 4TB WD40EFPX? Analyze head-to-head all specifications and features to find out the better hard disk. A lot of people hate on Seagate (including myself) because many years ago a whole batch of really bad drives had very high failure rates. Be aware that recent WD firmware has a 3 year timer that triggers Synology's Warning status, even if the drive is still good. After having a 50% failure rate and non-reallocation issues with WD WD60EFRX drives, I'm thinking of switching to Seagate IronWolf drives. 5" -WD40EFZX : Electronics Amazon. If building a TrueNAS system, WD Red Plus or Pro would be the way to go, the 8TB Red Plus model WD80EFPX is CMR and should be comparable in price to the IronWolf What server are you using? I want to upgrade one of my drives from a 5TB to a 10TB. Guys, What drive is folks in here using to power their NAS? Any pros and cons? Seagate 18TB is about $550 and WD would run $609, at the time for this writing. How I came to these conclusions: Obviously the main choices are: - Western Digital Red or Red Pro - Seagate IronWolf - Toshiba N300 Can anyone point me towards a demonstrable advantage to one of these choices? Is there a contender I missed? HGST perhaps? The price/performance seem to be nearly on par across the board. Both WD Red Plus and Seagate Ironwolf are quiet. Seagate Barracuda or WD red? Question? Basically these two have almost the same price What about quality? I have to add a couple of drives on a NAS and I would REEALLY like for it to last for at least 3 to 4 years Archived post. WD started introducing stuff that marks the drives as failing after 3 years to sell more drives. Its not going to help you to have those drives running as fast as they are. Confused between these two options. IronWolf: Non-Pro. How long will a 6TB record for, in this situation? Thank you. I'm looking at: - 18TB Toshiba N300 NAS Systems - 18TB Seagate Exos X18 - 18TB Western Digital - HC550 Go for WD. Oct 2, 2025 · The technologies of the NAS drives of the WD Red and Seagate IronWolf are similar. 6TB IronWolf or 4TB Red? And $/TB is the same? Go for the IronWolf. They are heaps cheaper than the WD Red, and marginally cheaper than the IronWolf. com: Seagate IronWolf 4TB NAS Internal Hard Drive HDD – CMR 3. I have the option between 10TB Toshiba N300- and 8TB Ironwolf (non pro) drives, where the Seagate drives are not only slower (5400 va 7200 RPM) but are the same price per drive, so prive per TB is worse. 0, USB 2. 4W idle), amounts to 41. What do you guys use in your NAS's and what has been your experience with reliability? WD Red or Seagate IronWolf NAS? Question? EDIT: Made up my mind, after looking at specs, I'll pull the trigger on the 4Tb IronWolf NAS, thanks!! Hi there! New to this subreddit, but long time data hoarder. First off, we just want to say thanks for considering Seagate, regardless of which route you decide is the best fit for your needs in the end. 8TB WD Red vs Ironwolf vs 2x4TB? So, lately I got some notifications and after doing an extended SMART Scan, one of my 2 Ironwolf ST8000VN0022 (SHR) shows a "mere" 60k bad sectors, so time to replace this one. This makes your hard drives warmer than usual. Seagate vs. Any negative experiences with the Seagate's? The ironWolf is cheaper and will save me good chunck of money but in case the WD Red 7200RPM is quieter then definitly will go for it. I know they won't be completely silent but I'm hoping to at least buy the most quiet one. The additional power consumption of a single IronWolf (6TB, ST6000VN0033, 8. They were from their Amazon Warehouse category and listed as “used like new”. Here are the drives I just pulled out. NAS drives like the WD Red Pro and Seagate Ironwolf Pro idle at about 4-5W and peak at about 7-8W, with the Red Pros using about 1W less than the Ironwolf Pro's at least on paper. The WD Red Pro and Seagate IronWolf Pro are the enhanced “Pro” versions of their respective NAS drive ranges. Sustained Transfer Rate) when IronWolf has 7200 rpm of spindle speed as standard from 6TB capacity, entire WD Red line has 5400 rpm only both Pro series have same 7200 rpm of spindle speed for all Hi there I just wanted to share my experience with two 6TB drives: -WD Red Plus WD60EFZX -Seagate IronWolf ST6000VN001 both bought around September to November 2021. I want to buy 5 drives of 4TB each for a NAS running ZFS with Raid-z2. 2 kWh/year. Planning on using them for a NAS. I'm between these 3 drives that I can find at $105 each: WD Red Plus WD40EFZX Seagate IronWolf ST4000VN008 Toshiba N300 HDWQ140XZSTA EDIT Seagate Exos ST4000NM0035 I'm leaning towards the Toshiba or the Seagate Exos drive because they are the only ones that run at 7200RPM. Unless Synology disables the WD feature, that means you won’t get good data on drive health. I had the WD Red Pro 4TB and they made the exact same noise on setup. Also both, WD & Seagate, are usually on point when it comes to RMA. WD barely audible, Ironwolf is clicking like ut was made 5 years ago. Feb 19, 2025 · Which wins between the Seagate IronWolf vs. there is no doubt, that RED vs IronWolf lines have similar basic performance specification (Max. Any thoughts? The Iron-Wolf is 2 or 3 years newer than my WD. Considering above scenarios, which hard drive (CMR vs SMR) should I purchase, and specifically which brand and model - Seagate IronWolf vs WD Red Plus (6 to 8TB size) Thank you Archived post. M. 1W idle) vs a single 6TB WD Red (3. Which HDDs offer the best value for performance, longevity, and price right now? 2 comments share save hide report all 2 comments sorted by: best top new controversial old q&a I'll go against the flow and say my Ironwolf drives are quieter and run cooler than the WDs. I have the same DS220+. Like I'm not so much worried about the quality as I am about the Shadiness. T monitoring, dubbed IHM (IronWolf Health Management). Pull up the data sheets. Btw, it isn't that Ironwolf is noisier than WD Red Plus. The red's have a 128MB cache vs 256MB cache, but more importantly the IronWolf is around 210MB/s vs. 0, and SATA 2. The 716+ is always busy, and has dual gigabit, so speed matters. Seagate IronWolf: A Detailed Comparison Performance: The IronWolf series generally offers better performance than the WD Red, particularly in demanding workloads. Jan 23, 2025 · The 12TB versions are all Helium filled but as you stated Ironwolf Pro is more tailored for performance (like red pro) while red plus is for noise and heat. (512 MB Cache vs 256 MB Cache). Obviously the main choices are: - Western Digital Red or Red Pro - Seagate IronWolf - Toshiba N300 Can anyone point me towards a demonstrable advantage to one of these choices? Is there a contender I missed? HGST perhaps? The price/performance seem to be nearly on par across the board. Will having a mixture, cause any issues? After a trial run with one camera I’m going to start building up my numbers and using my DS920+ as the NVR. For Seagate that's their IronWolf drives. I was thinking of making a RAID storage with WD Red Pro drives (or Ironwolf pro, undecided). From what I can tell, these are slightly louder than WD Red SMR, but are more quiet than the IronWolf Pro or WD Red Plus. Anyone use non-UniFi hard drives and have a recommendation? Or am I better off waiting for them to come back in stock? Apr 7, 2022 · Looking to upgrade my nas to 4tb. IronWolf Pro. This means you will not be notified when something really goes wrong with that drive (the NAS thinks it's already "bad" after all). After the WD issue with early end of life warnings in Synology i was thinking of replacing my WD Red Pro, over time, with IronWolf Pro drives. They are shuckable, external drives and are NAS quality drives that just didn't make the cut ( or were overproduction ) for WD Red drives. Ironwolf are CMR, but red pro is more comparable to ironwolf pro in terms of rated workload etc. I have a Synology that needs more storage. R. 5 We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. . In some ways they fail worse with zero warning and take all the data with it. That’s the extra cost of running the IronWolf. I personally would not pay almost 2x just to get different brand and slightly higher rated workload numbers (which are marketing anyway). These drives come with additional features that make them more suitable for professional use, particularly in large-scale NAS deployments or demanding workloads. Has anyone purchased renewed versions of any of these drives? Worth the lowered cost to lose 3 years of warranty? I have both in my DS4512+, Ironwolf runs cooler (-2 or -3° compared to WD), noise at idle or low load is similar, writes could be a little bit louder on Ironwolf since I added the disk to the array, but it's very subjective. I ordered a WD Black 8TB, but now the Red Plus is on sale for $34 cheaper, do you guys believe the Black is worth $34 more? The biggest difference that I know of is Black has a longer warranty 5 vs 3. I've seen others talking about the WD Purple/Red series. 0 Seagate IronWolf ( and also WD RED ) are just marketing. For WD that's their Red drives. I thought you must be referring to the normally cheaper SMR version. WD Red PRO 16TB vs Ironwolf Pro 16TB. Enterprise disks like the Ultrastar and Exos idle at about 5-6W and active load max out at 9-10W. SSD's are faster than HDD's, yes. Good or bad idea? The Plus (CMR) is super cheap if you skip the first WD plus option in the Amazon search results. Still with no bad sectors. One factor that stood out was 256MB vs. Practically everything is the same, everything has very similar failure rates, etc. WD Red? This shootout covers two enterprise-grade HDDs to see which is the absolute best. lm vk5vo ak5g3 vsvm4 n3dz7uc kvqohr wl8t7z 2xs6w szh byqf